Every year, service members PCSing out of Fort Carson face the same decision: sell the Colorado Springs house or keep it as a rental. The VA loan adds wrinkles to that decision that most people don't fully understand until they're already under the gun with orders in hand.
This post covers exactly what happens to your VA loan when you PCS and convert the property to a rental — your entitlement, your occupancy obligation, your BAH situation at the new duty station, and the most common mistakes people make in this scenario.
The Occupancy Requirement: What It Actually Says
VA loans require that the borrower intend to occupy the property as their primary residence. That's the rule at origination. What it does not say is that you must live there forever. The VA's own guidance acknowledges that military service members with VA loans may be required to vacate the property due to orders, and this is explicitly not a violation of the occupancy requirement.
When you receive PCS orders, you have a legitimate, documented reason to leave. Converting the property to a rental at that point is generally permissible. You don't need to notify the VA or your lender that you're converting to a rental — this isn't an FHA loan with investor restrictions. The loan stays in place, the terms don't change, and you continue making the same payment.
The one area to watch: if you had a streamline refinance (IRRRL) recently, there's a certification involved in that process. If you refinanced via IRRRL claiming it as your primary residence and then immediately converted to a rental, that creates a paperwork problem. But for standard purchases or cash-out refis done while you genuinely occupied the property, converting at PCS time is a clean situation.
What Happens to Your VA Entitlement
This is the part that surprises people. When you keep the Colorado Springs property and the VA loan stays active, that entitlement is tied up. You haven't sold, the loan hasn't been paid off, so the VA hasn't restored that entitlement.
However, you may still have remaining entitlement available — enough to use a second VA loan at your new duty station without a down payment. This depends on the loan amount on the Colorado Springs property relative to the conforming loan limit. If you borrowed significantly under the limit, you may have substantial entitlement still available. If you borrowed near or at the limit, your remaining entitlement may be small and a down payment may be required on the second purchase.
The only way to know for certain is to pull your Certificate of Eligibility before you start shopping at the new duty station. Your lender can do this in minutes. Don't estimate — the numbers matter, and the math is easy to get wrong without the actual COE in hand.
BAH at the New Duty Station
One of the cleaner aspects of this scenario: when you PCS, your BAH switches to the rate for your new duty station. You're no longer receiving Colorado Springs BAH — you get whatever the new MHA pays. That has nothing to do with whether you kept the Colorado Springs property or sold it. The BAH follows the soldier, not the house.
This means the Colorado Springs mortgage is now coming out of your own pocket — specifically, the rental income you collect. If the rental covers the mortgage plus a buffer, you're in good shape. If it doesn't quite cover it, you're supplementing from base pay or other income.
This is a math problem worth running carefully before you commit. What will the property rent for in the current Colorado Springs market? What is your all-in monthly cost (mortgage, insurance, property tax, HOA if applicable, vacancy cushion, maintenance reserve)? The gap between those two numbers tells you whether keeping the property makes financial sense.
The Rental Income Question for a Future VA Loan
If you plan to use a second VA loan at your new duty station and you want the Colorado Springs rental income to count toward qualifying, most lenders need a two-year history of rental income documented on tax returns. A lease agreement alone typically isn't enough for the income to help your DTI. If you've been renting the property for less than two years, you may not be able to count it — which means your qualification at the new duty station is based on your military income without that rental offset.
This doesn't necessarily prevent you from qualifying — your military income is stable and documented, and VA residual income requirements are structured to work at most pay grades. But it's something to know before you're sitting with a lender at the new station wondering why the rental income isn't helping your numbers.
Property Management: The Practical Reality
Managing a rental from a different duty station is doable but requires a plan before you PCS. Options range from full-service property managers (typically 8–12% of monthly rent in Colorado Springs) to self-managing with a reliable local contact. Full-service management is usually worth it when you're hundreds or thousands of miles away — the cost of one maintenance emergency that you can't respond to promptly often exceeds a year of management fees.
Screen tenants carefully before you leave. A bad tenant in a property you can't easily access is significantly more disruptive than a vacancy. Most property managers handle this, but if you're self-managing, take the time to run background and credit checks, verify income, and call previous landlords. The Colorado Springs rental market is healthy enough that you can afford to be selective.
When Selling Still Makes More Sense
Keeping the property isn't always the right call. If you bought recently and have minimal equity, if the rental income won't cover carrying costs, if the property needs significant deferred maintenance, or if you don't have the bandwidth to manage a landlord relationship from afar — selling on the way out is a completely legitimate choice. Colorado Springs has appreciated consistently, and selling gives you clean entitlement, cash proceeds, and a simpler financial picture at the new duty station.
The right answer depends on your equity position, the rent-to-mortgage ratio at current market rates, your timeline (how long you've owned it, how long until you might return), and honestly, your appetite for being a landlord. There's no universal right answer — but there is a right answer for your specific situation, and it's worth taking an hour to run the numbers before you decide.
If you're working through this decision and want a Colorado Springs perspective on what your property would rent for in today's market, reach out through the contact form below. This is exactly the kind of conversation I have with PCSing Fort Carson families regularly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to tell my lender I'm converting my VA loan home to a rental?
For a standard VA purchase loan, there's no notification requirement when you convert to a rental due to PCS orders. The loan terms don't change. If you have an FHA loan — different story. VA loans don't have the same investor restrictions FHA loans carry.
Can I get a second VA loan while still paying on the first?
Yes, in many cases. Second-tier (bonus) entitlement may allow you to purchase at the new duty station with zero down even with an active VA loan on the Colorado Springs property. The amount depends on your remaining entitlement — pull your COE to see the exact numbers before shopping.
What does a property manager cost in Colorado Springs?
Full-service property management in Colorado Springs typically runs 8–12% of monthly rent, plus a leasing fee (usually one month's rent) when placing a new tenant. For a property renting at $2,000/month, that's roughly $160–$240/month in management fees plus the periodic leasing fee. Worth it for most absentee landlords given the cost of mismanaged maintenance or tenant problems from a distance.
Will the rental income count when I apply for a VA loan at my next duty station?
Generally only if you have a two-year documented history of rental income on tax returns. A lease agreement doesn't substitute. If you're in the first year or two of renting the Colorado Springs property, lenders typically won't count that income — you qualify on military income alone.
Does keeping the Colorado Springs property affect my BAH at the new duty station?
No. Your BAH is set by your duty station location, pay grade, and dependency status. Whether you own, rent, or have sold a previous home has no effect on BAH calculation. BAH switches to the new MHA rate when you PCS, regardless of your Colorado Springs property situation.
What if the rent doesn't cover my mortgage payment?
That's a cash flow negative position — you're subsidizing the property monthly. Whether that makes sense depends on your equity trajectory, the tax benefits of rental property, and your long-term plan. Some families accept a small monthly shortfall for a property they intend to return to or hold long-term. Others decide the math doesn't work and sell. Run your actual numbers before committing either way.
Posted by Luke Martin onEnjoy this blog post? Click here to subscribe for updates
Leave A Comment