The rent vs. buy question comes up for almost every military family PCS'ing to Colorado Springs — and the honest answer is that it depends on factors specific to your situation rather than a universal rule. Tour length, pay grade, family size, risk tolerance, and long-term plans all factor in. Here's how to think through it clearly so you can make the right call for your family rather than defaulting to what everyone else seems to be doing.
The Case for Renting After PCS
Renting makes the most financial sense when your tour is short — two years or less — or when you're genuinely uncertain about the area and want time to learn the neighborhoods before committing. Real estate transaction costs run 6% to 8% of the purchase price when you add up closing costs on the buy side and agent commissions and closing costs on the sell side. On a $420,000 Colorado Springs home, that's $25,000 to $34,000 in transaction friction that you need to overcome through appreciation and equity building just to break even. At two years, that math is tight. At three years or more, the equation shifts considerably. Renting also preserves flexibility — if your orders change, a deployment extends, or a family situation changes, you're not trying to sell a house under pressure with a fixed timeline.
The Case for Buying After PCS
Buying makes the most sense when your tour is three years or longer, especially if you plan to keep the property as a rental when you PCS out. Colorado Springs has one of the strongest military rental markets in the country — five installations generating consistent BAH-backed demand year-round means incoming military families will want to rent your home when you leave. The VA loan eliminates the down payment barrier that keeps most civilian buyers on the sidelines, and the no-PMI structure saves $150 to $300 per month compared to a conventional loan at the same purchase price. Families who bought near Fort Carson, Peterson SFB, or Schriever at almost any point in the past decade and held the property as a rental have generally seen strong returns — consistent rental income, meaningful appreciation, and a growing portfolio that doesn't require selling between assignments.
The Break-Even Timeline for Colorado Springs
In the current Colorado Springs market, the break-even point — the point at which buying beats renting financially — generally falls around 24 to 30 months depending on your specific purchase price, mortgage rate, and neighborhood appreciation rate. At current VA loan rates and Colorado Springs median prices, a family buying at month one and selling at month 24 is roughly breaking even after transaction costs. At month 36 they're meaningfully ahead. At month 48 or beyond, with a VA loan and no PMI, buying almost always wins clearly. Run the specific numbers for your situation — purchase price, estimated rent for a comparable property, mortgage payment, and expected appreciation — before making the decision.
What to Do If You're Unsure
If you're genuinely torn, a hybrid approach works well for many Colorado Springs families. Rent for the first 6 to 12 months to learn the city, find the neighborhoods you actually like, understand the commute patterns from different parts of the metro to your specific gate, and get your kids settled in school. Then buy with the remaining tour length in mind. You lose a year of potential appreciation but you buy with much more confidence and far less chance of landing in the wrong neighborhood for your lifestyle. Given how long some Colorado Springs tours run — three to four years is common at all five installations — a year of renting before buying still leaves plenty of time to build equity and position the property as a long-term rental.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I rent or buy when PCS'ing to Colorado Springs?
Tour length is the primary factor. Two years or less — renting is almost always the better financial choice given transaction costs. Three or more years, especially with plans to keep the property as a rental after PCS — buying with a VA loan often makes more financial sense given Colorado Springs' strong military rental market.
How long does it take for buying to beat renting in Colorado Springs?
In the current market, the break-even point generally falls around 24 to 30 months depending on purchase price, mortgage rate, and neighborhood. At 36 months with a VA loan and no PMI, buying almost always comes out ahead.
Can I rent out my Colorado Springs home when I PCS out?
Yes. Colorado Springs has one of the strongest military rental markets in the country. Five installations generate consistent year-round demand from incoming families. Properties near Fort Carson, Peterson SFB, and Schriever that are well-maintained and priced to BAH typically rent quickly and hold low vacancy rates.
What are the transaction costs of buying and selling a home in Colorado Springs?
Total transaction costs — closing costs on the buy side plus agent commissions and closing costs on the sell side — typically run 6% to 8% of the purchase price. On a $420,000 home that's $25,000 to $34,000 in friction that needs to be overcome through appreciation and equity building before you come out ahead of renting.
Is a VA loan better than renting for military families in Colorado Springs?
For tours of three years or longer, the VA loan's zero down payment and no PMI requirement often make buying more financially advantageous than renting — especially when the property is held as a rental after PCS rather than sold. Run the specific numbers for your tour length and local market before deciding.
Posted by Luke Martin onEnjoy this blog post? Click here to subscribe for updates
Leave A Comment